A debate has emerged in India after the West Bengal government piloted changes to school lunch menus in some schools by removing "eggs" and substituting them with vegetarian protein options, raising concerns about children's nutrition.
It has sparked heavy criticism as India's school lunch program—one of the world's largest child welfare initiatives supporting over 110 million children—plans to alter menus by eliminating eggs from meals served to students.
For many children, especially those from poor families, this meal serves as a primary source of nutrition and sometimes the only meal of the day, playing a vital role in reducing malnutrition, hunger, and encouraging regular school attendance.
The controversy began when the West Bengal government, led by the Bharatiya Janata Party (BJP) which recently won elections, assigned the Hindu religious organization International Society for Krishna Consciousness (ISKCON), also known as the "Hare Krishna" movement, to manage school lunch production for municipal schools in Kolkata.
All meals will be provided through the Annamitra Foundation, which serves exclusively vegetarian food, resulting in egg dishes being replaced with plant-based proteins such as soybeans or red beans.
Although the project is still under discussion and has not yet been implemented, it has already sparked nationwide criticism.
The All India Trinamool Congress (TMC), the previous ruling party, accused the BJP government of pushing vegetarian ideology on students for ideological reasons.
Many critics argue that menu decisions should not be influenced by religious beliefs or politics but should prioritize nutritional value.
Meanwhile, supporters of the program say that if menus are properly planned, vegetarian meals can provide nutritional value comparable to eggs.
Several nutrition experts emphasize that eggs are a high-quality, affordable protein source ideally suited for growing children.
In India, one egg costs about 8 rupees (less than 4 baht) and contains all nine essential amino acids as well as vitamin D and vitamin B12, which are vital for children's development.
Although foods like paneer (Indian fresh cheese) or dairy products provide similar nutrients, their much higher cost makes them difficult to include in government-funded school lunch programs.
Experts warn that removing eggs without appropriate nutritional replacements may cause children to receive insufficient protein and essential nutrients, potentially affecting growth, learning, and immune systems in the long term.
Some parents say having eggs in school lunches assures them their children get enough protein, while some students express curiosity about trying new menus but many feel disappointed as they looked forward to special egg meals.
Teachers in several states emphasize that school lunches are crucial for encouraging poor children to attend regularly, as many come to school without having eaten breakfast.
In some areas, like Bihar state, schools have adopted a compromise by allowing students to choose: those who eat eggs receive them, while those who do not are given bananas instead, respecting differences in beliefs and eating habits.
,BBC
Click to read more about International News