;
Thairath Online
Thairath Online

Sahasawat Asks Julapan if He Has Read the Warnings from Three Agencies About the 3 Requests Before Pushing Social Security Bill to Parliament

Politic17 Nov 2026 19:08 GMT+7

Share

Sahasawat Asks Julapan if He Has Read the Warnings from Three Agencies About the 3 Requests Before Pushing Social Security Bill to Parliament

Sahasawat presented documents from the National Economic and Social Development Council, Bank of Thailand, and the Office of the Council of State, which had warned that the '3 Requests' risk destroying the social security fund and contradict the law's intent. He asked Julapan whether he had ever read these before pushing the social security draft into Parliament.


On 17 Nov 2026 GMT+7, Sahasawat Koomkong, Chonburi MP from the People’s Party, spoke regarding the Cabinet’s proposal of the Social Security Act (No. ..) B.E. .... which includes the principle of the '3 Requests' (request to choose, request to withdraw, request to borrow) and is scheduled for parliamentary consideration tomorrow. He shared important documents for public and insured persons to review: four legal and economic opinions from three key state agencies—the National Economic and Social Development Council (NESDC), Bank of Thailand, and the Office of the Council of State. These agencies officially raised objections in 2022 when the previous government attempted to push the '3 Requests' principle, which includes requesting to receive lump-sum payments instead of pensions, early withdrawal of old-age funds, and using old-age funds as loan collateral.


Sahasawat explained he understands well why many workers desire these rights, as in times of income loss or overwhelming debt, immediate cash is urgently needed to survive. However, if the government allows early withdrawal of old-age funds, it must clearly answer the public: how much retirement income will remain when the insured can no longer work? This concern has been firmly warned by policy agencies since 2022.


He continued that reviewing the documents, the NESDC clearly warned that if the social security fund must hold large cash reserves to repay insured persons, it would force the fund to reduce long-term investments, directly impacting returns and financial stability. The Bank of Thailand expressed concerns about both the fund's security and the income security of insured persons who withdraw early or use funds as loan collateral. The Office of the Council of State straightforwardly stated that permitting early use of old-age funds contradicts the Social Security Act’s intent to protect and guarantee income for workers in old age.


“I want to ask directly the Minister of Labor and the government: before dusting off the '3 Requests' draft and pushing it through Cabinet in 2026, did you ever read the opinions from these three agencies? After Cabinet approval, how did the Ministry of Labor assess these objections? How much burden can the fund bear, and how much retirement income will remain for insured persons who exercise these rights? Will the government disclose these studies and clarifications to the insured?” Sahasawat questioned.


Additionally, Sahasawat pointed out that regarding retirees’ income, the NESDC proactively suggested in document No. 1108/921 (page 2, item 4(2)) to promptly revise the pension calculation method to be based on wages over the entire contribution period, adjusting past wages to current value before averaging. This principle matches the 'CARE pension formula,' which truly reflects lifetime earnings and ensures fairness for workers with decreasing or uncertain income near the end of their careers, preventing the last 60-month salary base from unfairly lowering pensions.


Sahasawat concluded that the CARE pension formula, widely agreed upon by academics and experts as urgent, was approved by the Social Security Board in March 2025 and received Cabinet principle approval on 14 July 2026. Yet, as of late October, the Minister still claims it is under Council of State review, with no official announcement in the Royal Gazette. This means another 180 days must pass after announcement before enforcement. In summary, the beneficial CARE formula proceeds slowly, while the '3 Requests' draft, which has faced legal and economic objections since 2022, is hastily pushed forward. He asked whether the minister has responded to these objections for the insured or is just rushing the bill through and planning to find answers later.